Trending
Before I go anywhere with this article, I want to acknowledge something.
Portfolio reviews work.
Sort of.
They are the industry standard for a reason. Advisors have been using some version of this offer for the better part of fifty years, and the entire profession is built on top of it. If you walk into a thousand advisors’ offices today and ask what their primary marketing offer is, the majority will tell you a variation of “I do a free initial consultation.”
And some of those advisors are doing just fine. They build businesses and have great lives.
So when I tell you that free portfolio reviews are bad offers, I’m not saying they never work. I am saying they usually work despite themselves.
The truth is that advisors who succeed with free reviews typically do so because of their personality, network, referrals, tenure in the industry, or sheer volume of meetings they’re willing to take.
The offer itself is contributing almost nothing to their success. It’s a leaky bucket that they’re keeping full by pouring water in faster than it leaks out.
That's a fine strategy if you have an unlimited supply of water.
Most advisors don't.
I want to talk to you today because the moment you understand what's actually happening with the free portfolio review, you'll see one of the highest-leverage opportunities in your entire business.
Let me start with a question.
Of the last one hundred prospects you encountered, how many of them came to you saying, “I really need someone to look at my portfolio?” (Assuming you didn’t tell them or prompt them to say that.)
I’d bet the answer is close to zero.
Because prospects walk in worried about other things. They worry about:
- Running out of money in retirement.
- What happens to their spouse if they die first?
- A market crash hitting right before they retire.
- Passing what they built to their children without Uncle Sam taking a bite.
- If their adult children are ever going to figure out their finances.
- If they should’ve converted to Roth five years ago.
- Whether the inheritance from their parents will trigger something they don’t understand.
They worry about a thousand specific human things that are keeping them up at night.
Not one of them is lying awake thinking, "If only someone would review my portfolio."
The free portfolio review does not speak to any of that.
Which means the advisors who get clients from free reviews are doing so by working around the offer, not because of it. They are using their personality, their credibility, their referral network, or the sheer luck of having a prospect who was already 80% sold before the meeting started.
Put another way...
Free portfolio reviews don't generate clients. Advisors generate clients despite free portfolio reviews.
Here's what this means for your business…
If you are closing a percentage of free-review prospects right now, that is your baseline.
Now imagine taking everything you already do well and pointing it at an offer that your market actually has a burning desire for. An offer that enters the conversation already happening inside your prospects’ heads.
What happens to your booking rate? And your close rate?
They both go up, usually by multiples.
I have seen advisors more than double their conversion rates in a single quarter, doing NOTHING other than changing the offer(s) they lead with.
Everything else stayed the same. They had the same prospects walking in the door and the same process in their meetings. The only thing that changed was the offer.
Let me walk you through the math so I can prove it to you...
I want you to imagine that 1,000 prospects encounter your marketing over the next twelve months.
Let's say that your primary offer is a free portfolio review. That's the industry standard. Lots of financial advisors lead with some version of it.
Of those 1,000 prospects, maybe 2% find a free portfolio review compelling enough to actually book the meeting. That gives you 20 conversations.
Let’s also assume that you are great at the “sales” part of your business, and you’re able to close half of those 20 conversations.
That’s 10 new clients.
Alright, hold that number in your head. 10 clients.
Now, let’s run the same exercise with a different offer.
We’ll keep everything else the same. You have the same 1,000 prospects from the same marketing channels. But this time, instead of offering a free portfolio review, you offer something specific that the market wants a LOT more. Something like an "In Case of Emergency" planning engagement for the spouse who handles the family finances. Priced at $1,200, with a specific deliverable and a six-week turnaround. (I’m just brainstorming here. This is not a real offer.)
Of those 1,000 prospects, maybe 10% find that offer compelling. That’s 100 conversations. Five times more than before.
And let’s say that you’re a horrible salesperson. Your meeting process is awkward, you stumble over your words, and you don’t have a defined process for closing prospects. So, we’ll assume that your closing rate is 25%, half of the first advisor’s.
You would STILL get 25 clients.
Did you catch that?
Your sales skills could be awful, and you could still get 250% more clients than the other guy.
That’s why I keep telling financial advisors that the offer is the single highest-leverage thing they can change in their business.
I see so many financial advisors trying to improve their marketing and sales parts of their businesses. And, don’t get me wrong, those things are important. But if you have a bad offer, then improving those things is like putting lipstick on a pig.
I know I’m the “financial advisor marketing” guy, but I must tell you the truth…
In many cases, the trick to rapidly improving a financial advisor’s results has NOTHING to do with marketing and everything to do with the offer the financial advisor presents to the marketplace.
This is why I tell advisors that the offer is the single highest-leverage thing they can change in their business. Every other piece of marketing you do gets amplified or muted by the offer underneath. If the offer is mismatched, all of the marketing on top of it is fighting an uphill battle. If the offer is well-matched, the marketing starts to pull its full weight for the first time.
That’s the reason why two financial advisors can spend the exact same amount of money on marketing targeting the same niche and get vastly different results.
Because marketing is merely an amplifier. It doesn’t create demand from nothing.
If you point a brilliant marketer at an offer the market doesn't care about, the result is zero clients. If you point a mediocre marketer at an offer the market actually wants, the result is more clients than they can handle.