What a 19th-Century Hotel Can Teach You About Timeless Brand Loyalty

Imagine building a brand so beloved… people gladly take a horse and carriage to get there.

Before that moment, the journey sets the tone. You can fly into Pellston Regional amid tall pines, shuttle to the docks, or drive north across the Mighty Mac to St. Ignace or into Mackinaw City. You leave the car. Porters tag your bags. The ferry cuts across the blue of Lake Huron.

Flags, lilacs, and bikes appear on the shoreline as the island comes into view. (And yes, Mackinac is pronounced exactly the same as Mackinaw. Don’t ask me about the spelling. Island life just works that way.)

Article content

 

Your luggage goes straight to the hotel. You step onto Main Street. Horses clip-clop past. You slow down before you even realize it.

 

Not for the novelty. Not for the content. Because it is the only way.

Article content

Welcome to the Grand Hotel on Mackinac Island, Michigan. No cars. No chain restaurants. No modern chaos. Yet every summer it captures the internet’s heart and books out months in advance.

This is not a fad. It is a century-long masterclass in brand building.

The lessons are as relevant to marketers in 2025 as they were to hoteliers in 1887.

Article content

A porch that built a brand

The Grand Hotel’s front porch stretches 660 feet, the longest in the world. White rocking chairs. Striped awnings. The Straits of Mackinac shimmering below.

It’s not just architecture. It’s the kind of brand asset most companies spend decades trying to invent.

Built in 1887. Still fully booked

Funded by railroads and steamships, the Grand was designed to control both the journey and the destination—the original “vertical integration.”

It worked in 1887. It still works now.

No cars. No chaos. No regrets

On July 6, 1898, Mackinac Island banned automobiles to protect horses and preserve the quiet.

Guests arrive by ferry, then by horse-drawn carriage.

What some would call a limitation is, in fact, the opening chapter of the guest experience.

Attire that elevates the moment

After 6:30 p.m., formal evening wear transforms dinner into ritual at The Grand Hotel. Coats and ties for men. Dresses or pantsuits for women. Forgot your tie? The lobby can help.

The point is not the dress code—it’s the feeling you get when the dining room doors open and everyone looks like they’re walking into a gala.

Secret Garden: the hidden signature

Tucked just out of sight, the Secret Garden rewards those who wander. Early spring bulbs give way to summer annuals, framed by carefully manicured paths. It’s the perfect spot for an afternoon pause… or for pretending you stumbled upon something no one else knows about.

Article content

Design that differentiates

Inside, nothing feels copy-pasted. Dorothy Draper & Company, Inc.—guided for decades by Carleton Varney—gave each of the nearly 400 rooms a unique personality.

Some suites are named for First Ladies. The public spaces are theatrical: bold florals, pink-striped walls, and that famous red-and-black English needlepoint-style carpet that’s practically a celebrity in its own right.

Design here doesn’t whisper. It sings

Article content

Somewhere in Time still filling rooms

The 1980 romance filmed at the Grand struggled at the box office, then found a cult following. Each fall, fans return in Edwardian attire for a themed weekend—because nostalgia is stronger when you can literally step back in time.

After dinner: down to the water

Walk down to Main Street and onto the harbor for the Carriage House at Hotel Iroquois—a waterfront restaurant where every table has a view of sailboats and sunset light. White linens. Fresh lake fish. A breeze that makes you linger over dessert.

If you’re after more energy, the Pink Pony delivers rum runners, live music, and a patio that might just convince you to stay “five more minutes” until closing. Both are traditions in their own right.

What every brand can learn

  • Scarcity creates desire — One island. One hotel. One short season.
  • Constraints create identity — No cars. Horses as the soundtrack. Quiet nights.
  • Design is differentiation — Bold color stories, famous carpet, named suites.
  • Rituals drive loyalty — Afternoon tea. Formal dinners. The longest porch in the world.
  • Experience is the product — From the ferry to the carriage to the last piano note in the Parlor.

Vintage vibes. Viral impact

Every summer, feeds fill with striped awnings, sundresses, secret garden paths, and plates by the water.

The Grand Hotel doesn’t need a content strategy. It is the content. That’s the flywheel most brands dream of.

Final thought

The Grand Hotel doesn’t chase trends. It stands still with intention—and the world comes to it.

In an era obsessed with speed and scale, it proves that clarity, consistency, and courage build brands that last.

Ask yourself: Would people take a horse and carriage to get here?

If not… build something worth the journey.

Article content

Related: How Agentic AI Could Reshape the Future of Software Stocks